This is the important sloka in Viveka choodamani. If not
interpret properly, the whole of shastras will become useless.
"Vakvaikhari shabdajhari shastravyakhyana kaushalam ...
bhuktaye na tu muktaye" is a beautiful sloka in VivekaChoodamani by
Acharya. People often mistake this meaning. It is generally interpret as, the
proficiency , word games (using flowery words) and knowledge in interpreting
the Shastras may be useful in experiencing the things in the world but will not
be useful for Moksha. This is not just interpret in this way, but, the Vidwans
who interpret it this way also use this as a Pramana to ridicule the study of
shastra. They also for their support, bring the Sruthi, “vak viglapanam hi tat”
– it is just waste of energy.
But, then did not Acharya say this? Yes he did. But then
what is your problem, why are you condemning it? To condemn it, means is a
Blasphemy for me. The reason I say is it is not interpret properly, as always is
done by the ignorant (of the shastra).
How should it be interpret than?
First, if the before said meaning is what Acharya means,
than, the rest of the text will be redundant, like the other shastras and
interpretation of Acharya. And, after this (believe it is 50 or some sloka) He
writes around 400 more slokas.
Second, there are three beautiful, romantic, poetic masterly
Sanskrit words which are used in the
first part of the Sloka.
Vakvaikhari – expanse of the usage of words
Shabdajhari – the nuances of the words
Shastravyakhana-Kaushalam – ability to interpret the words.
But, the really mean, from the introduction invocation sloka
of Taiteriya Bhashya, “yairime gurubhi purvam padavakyapramanata” - the earlier Guru’s who through Pada,
Vakya and Pramana.
Pada means Grammar, Vakya means Poorva Mimamsa and Pramana
means Nyaya.
In the same way here too, Acharya uses these three words
respectively.
Vakvaikhari means Pada means Grammar. Trough Grammar one
understands the right meaning and usage of the words, and therefore has a very
thorough grasp over the vak, speech.
Shabdajhari means Vakya
means Poorva Mimamsa. Through mimamsa one understands the way to interpret the
words and staments of the Shastra using the different meters (pointers – linga)
said in it.
And, Shastravyakhana-Kaushalam means Pramana means Nyaya. With logic one is able to prove or disprove
the desired and non-desired.
By this understanding, we can synchronize the sruti statement
“Anyaan vaacho vimunvhatha amrtasya esha setu: “ – give up the other useless
talk, (involve only in shastra discussion), this is the means of eternality.
In essence, Acharya says, don’t waste your time and energy
in only the futile pursuit of the other shastras, learn it to use it in
Vedanta. Meaning, Study the Vedanta Properly.
No comments:
Post a Comment